This post will grow over time as I collect all the links involved but here is the unfolding of a little cryptozoological conundrum we were involved in that wound up getting mentioned in the 2006 book Haunted Minnesota by Hugh E. Bishop.
It all started with the following post that I put on a local weblog on 2-14-05, using bad grammar posting as “The Professor”, and using the old Gonzo Science blog url:
“Unidentified Tracks Found by Duluth Campers”.
That followed with a report of alleged Bigfoot prints in the Great North Woods posted on a local weblog by “Vicarious” on 3-5-05:
“Um, This Is Kind of Weird But…”
He followed up by posting photos on 3-9-05:
“You Wanted Photos?”
Gonzo Science consulted Loren Coleman, who couldn’t tell anything from the photos. We also got an email or two from woodsy folks who assured us the photos could be body prints of a baby bounding deer, which can morph rather easily (with infalling snow and a little melting) into “Bigfoot prints”. Eventually we called it for the baby deer explanation, on account of all other things being equal, the deer explanation was more conservative. (That was published in the Reader Weekly but they have no online archives. Might be able to find the old file around here somewhere…)
Later the incident made a discussion board at www.virtuallystrange.net (sign in required or I’d give the url). This is apparently where writer Hugh E. Bishop picked it up, and it made pages 111-112 of his 2006 book Haunted Minnesota; he describes us as “Fortean researchers”.
Vicarious always maintained it was not a bounding baby deer that made the prints. We always gave him a lot of credence as a first-hand witness of these tracks, so similar to the previous report of tracks from the same region, a report which in fact had been made by good and trusted friends of ours, the previous month. And of course, we have repudiated the criteria of conservatism extensively in other media, and so there you go.
These days, since 12,000-year-old Hobbit fossils have been more-or-less accepted as the genuine article by the establishment, all bets are off.
And that is the legend of the Haunted Minnesota Bigfoot.